November 18, 2026Last updated: November 18, 202611 min read12 sections
What to Look For When Hiring a Podcast Promotion Agency: 12 Questions to Ask
By Tom Hunt, Founder & CEO, Fame
Tom founded Fame in 2019 and leads the company today, including Fame Search, its AI search agency for B2B companies. LinkedIn
Key Takeaways
- "Podcast promotion" can mean clips, ads or outreach, so two proposals are often for different jobs. Ask every agency the same 12 questions.
- Get the channel list in writing, split into owned, earned and paid, and ask who pays for ad spend.
- Ask what counts as a download, where paid listeners come from and whether they stay.
- A credible guarantee names a number the agency measures, a period and a remedy. A promise about your revenue is not credible.
- Promotion multiplies what is already there, so a good agency checks the show before it promises growth.
This guide is for B2B marketing leaders who already have a podcast and are about to pay someone to grow its audience. It gives you 12 questions to put to every podcast promotion agency on your shortlist, a scorecard to copy, and Fame's own answers at the end.
To choose a podcast promotion agency, ask each one the same 12 questions about fit, channels, paid media, measurement, commitments, price and people, and give most credit to answers you can check in writing.
This is a buyer's checklist, not a list of agencies. If you want names, see our list of the best podcast promotion agencies. If you would rather do the work in-house, start with how to grow a podcast.
Why is comparing podcast promotion agencies so hard?
Comparing podcast promotion agencies is hard because "promotion" and "marketing" are used for very different jobs, and most agencies only give a price on a call.
One agency means cutting clips and posting them. Another means buying ads in podcast apps. A third means pitching your show to newsletters and other hosts. All three call it podcast promotion, and some call it podcast marketing.
The result is hard to compare too. A download is not counted the same way everywhere, and a paid download is not worth the same as a listener who found you through a guest they trust.
So two proposals can promise the same growth and mean different things. The fix is to ask every agency the same questions and write the answers down.
What should you ask about fit before anything else?
Ask what the agency would check before it promises anything, because promotion multiplies what is already there.
Question 1: What would you look at before you tell us this show can grow? A good agency listens to episodes, looks at your current numbers and asks who the show is for. It may tell you to fix the show first. That is a good sign. Promoting a show the right people do not finish is an expensive way to find that out.
Question 2: Who is the listener we want, and where will you find more of them? In B2B, a few hundred of the right buyers beats tens of thousands of strangers. A good answer names a job title or a type of company, and then names the places those people already spend time. A weak answer is a download number with no person attached.
Which channels should a podcast promotion agency use?
A podcast promotion agency should give you a written list of the channels it works on for every episode, and say which are owned, earned and paid.
Question 3: Which channels do you use on every episode? Ask for the list, not a description. Owned channels are things you control, such as your website, newsletter and social profiles. Earned ones are guests sharing, partner swaps and communities. Paid ones are ads and sponsored placements. One channel is a tactic. A plan covers all three, as we set out in our podcast marketing strategy guide.
Question 4: What do you need from us to do it? Promotion is never fully hands-off. The agency may need access to your hosting account, your social profiles, your newsletter and your guests. Ask for the list now, and how many hours a month it will take from your team. A weak answer is "nothing, we handle it all".
How should paid promotion be handled?
Paid promotion should be priced separately from the agency's fee, run in accounts you can see, and judged on whether the listeners it buys stay.
Question 5: Who pays for ad spend, and do you add a mark-up? Ask whether media budget sits inside the fee or on top, whose ad accounts are used, and whether the agency takes a percentage. None of these models is wrong. You just need to know which one you are buying.
Question 6: Where do paid downloads come from, and how do you know they are real listeners? Ask which platforms and which shows the placements run on. Then ask what happens after the download: how much of the episode those people play, and whether they follow the show. Our guide to paid podcast promotion covers the options. A weak answer is a big number and no detail on where it came from.
How should growth be measured and reported?
Growth should be measured with a defined download count, reported on a fixed schedule, and broken down by what caused it.
Question 7: What do you report, how often, and what counts as a download? Ask for a real sample report. Ask how a download is defined and whether video views are in the figure. Ask for followers and completion as well, because a show can add downloads and lose listeners at the same time.
Question 8: How do you show which channel caused the growth, and how does it connect to pipeline? If downloads rise, you should be told why. Then ask about revenue. There are two routes in B2B: listeners who become leads, and guests who become customers or partners. Ask how each is tracked and what the agency needs from your sales team.
What should an agency commit to?
An agency should commit to a number it measures, a period to hit it in and a remedy if it misses, all in writing.
Question 9: Do you guarantee growth, on which number, and what happens if you miss? No agency can promise customers from a podcast. It can commit to something it measures, such as downloads. Ask for the number, the period and the remedy.
Question 10: How long before we should see growth, and what happens when we stop? Search and guest relationships build slowly and tend to last. Paid campaigns move numbers quickly and stop when the spend stops. A good answer tells you what to expect in month one, month three and month six, and which gains you keep if you end the contract.
What should you ask about price, terms and people?
Ask for the full monthly cost including ad spend, the minimum term, the notice period, what you keep, and who does the work.
Question 11: What is the full price, what is the commitment, and what do we keep if we leave?
- Fee. The monthly fee and what it covers.
- Ad budget. How much is recommended on top, and who controls it.
- Minimum term. How long you are committed for.
- Notice. How much notice you give, and whether you are billed during it.
- What you keep. The ad accounts, the audience data, the clips and the written assets.
An agency that does not publish pricing is not automatically a poor choice. Ask for the figure in writing before the second call.
Question 12: Who will work on our show, and how are AI tools used? Ask who your day-to-day contact is and how often you meet. Ask where AI tools are used and who checks the output. Using them is normal. Publishing unchecked clips and posts under your brand is the risk.
What are the red flags when hiring a podcast promotion agency?
The main red flags are a growth promise made before anyone has listened to the show, guaranteed revenue, one channel sold as a strategy, paid downloads with no source and reports with no definitions.
None of these proves an agency is bad. Each needs a clear explanation.
- A promise before a listen. The proposal arrives with a growth figure and nobody has asked who the show is for.
- Guaranteed leads or revenue. A commitment on something the agency measures is credible. A promise about your sales is not.
- One channel. Clips only, or ads only, described as a full promotion plan.
- Downloads with no source. Nobody can tell you where the new listeners came from or whether they stayed.
- Hidden media costs. You cannot see what was spent on ads and what was kept as fee.
- A long lock-in before you have seen a report. A minimum term is reasonable. A long one with no early exit moves the risk to you.
One red flag is a reason for a follow-up question. Several are a reason to keep looking.
What does a scorecard you can copy look like?
A scorecard is one row per question, scored 0 to 2 for each agency and filled in straight after each call.
Score 0 for no clear answer, 1 for a clear answer without evidence and 2 for a clear answer in writing or with evidence you have seen. The maximum is 24. Use the total to compare agencies, not as a pass mark.
| Area | Question | What a good answer looks like | What a weak answer looks like | Score (0-2) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fit | 1. What you check first | A review of the show, its listeners and its numbers before any plan | A plan before anyone has listened | |
| Fit | 2. Who the listener is | A named buyer and where that person spends time | "More downloads" | |
| Channels | 3. The channel list | A written list, split into owned, earned and paid | "We post clips on social" | |
| Channels | 4. What you provide | A list of access, assets and approvals, with hours a month | Demands that appear later | |
| Paid | 5. Ad spend | Who pays, who owns the accounts, any mark-up stated | A single fee with media hidden inside | |
| Paid | 6. Quality of paid listeners | Placements named, with completion and follower data | A download total with no source | |
| Measurement | 7. Reporting | A real sample report and a clear definition of a download | A number with no definition | |
| Measurement | 8. Cause and pipeline | Growth shown by channel, listeners and guests tied to your site and CRM | A download chart only | |
| Commitment | 9. Guarantee | A measured commitment and a remedy, in writing | Guaranteed revenue, or no commitment at all | |
| Commitment | 10. Timeline | What to expect by month, and what lasts after you stop | "Results in week one" | |
| Cost | 11. Price and terms | Fee, ad budget, minimum term, notice and what you keep, in writing | Terms left vague | |
| People | 12. Who does the work | Names, roles and who checks AI output | "A dedicated team", no names |
How does Fame answer these questions?
Fame publishes this guide and sells podcast promotion, so score our answers the same way as anyone else's.
- What we check first (1). We start with whether the show helps its ideal listener with a real challenge. If it does not, we will say it needs to go back to the drawing board before anyone promotes it.
- Who the listener is (2). We only work on B2B podcasts, and what we do comes from 300+ B2B shows produced since 2019.
- The channel list (3). Every episode goes through the same 8 pillars: SEO and AEO, organic social, guest sharing, partnerships and communities, paid platforms and influencers, paid podcasts, cold email and existing client assets. The cycle is organic first.
- What you provide (4). Two of the pillars depend on you: your guests, and assets you already own such as your website and newsletter. The more of those you bring, the more we have to work with.
- Ad spend (5). Paid ad budget is separate from our fee. If paid makes sense, we recommend a budget and you control it.
- Paid listeners (6). Paid platforms and paid placements on other podcasts are two pillars out of eight, not the whole plan. We read completion and followers alongside downloads.
- Reporting (7). Growth Radar, part of our platform, scores every show every day: downloads against the guarantee, followers and completion. You see it in your client portal, and your strategist sees the same screen.
- Cause and pipeline (8). Growth Radar shows which episodes and which pillars moved the number, and our reporting follows listeners from the episode to your site. For Zenoti's Growth Diaries, subscribers across all directories went from 19K to 265K+, as set out in the Zenoti case study.
- Guarantee (9). We guarantee an average of 10% monthly download growth over your first six months. If we miss it, month seven is free. The guarantee covers downloads. It does not cover pipeline.
- Timeline (10). Six months is the window we ask to be judged on, because that is the period the guarantee is measured over.
- Price and terms (11). Promotion only for an existing show starts from $3,000 a month, and it is on our pricing page. Plans are billed monthly. Ask us for the exact terms for your show and get them in writing.
- People (12). A strategist runs your show's promotion, on software we built for the job, from a fully remote team of 69 people in 16 countries.
The same approach is described on our podcast marketing services page.
When is Fame not the right fit?
Fame is not the right fit for consumer shows, promotion budgets under $3,000 a month, or teams that need a promise about revenue.
- You are not a B2B company. We only promote B2B shows. A consumer, entertainment or narrative show will be better served elsewhere.
- Your budget is under $3,000 a month. That is where promotion only starts, before any ad budget. For a small show that is a real commitment.
- You do not have a show yet. Promotion only is for an existing podcast. If you need the show made as well, Fame Podcast plans include guests, production and promotion of every episode.
- You want a pipeline guarantee. Ours is measured in downloads. Downloads are not pipeline, so you still need a plan for turning listeners and guests into revenue.
- You want one channel run in isolation. We run the full 8-pillar cycle. If you only want someone to manage ads, a paid media specialist is a better fit.
More on podcast promotion
- 8 Actionable Pillars For Promoting A Podcast
- Earned Media vs Paid Media: How to Grow Your Podcast
- What to Look For When Hiring a B2B Podcast Agency: 12 Questions to Ask
Want our answers for your show? Tell us about the podcast you already have, get a proposal, and we will come back with a promotion plan for it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ask every agency on your shortlist the same 12 questions, covering fit, channels, paid media, measurement, commitments, price and who does the work. Score each answer from 0 to 2 and give most credit to answers in writing or backed by evidence you have seen.
A podcast promotion agency grows the audience of a podcast that already exists. The work usually combines owned channels such as your website and newsletter, earned ones such as guest sharing and partnerships, and paid ones such as ads and placements on other podcasts.
This is different from a production agency, which makes the episodes.
In practice the two terms are used for the same thing: growing the audience of an existing show. Because the labels overlap, ignore the name and ask for the written list of channels the agency works on for every episode.
It depends on scope, and many agencies only quote on a call. Fame publishes its starting price: promotion only for an existing show is from $3,000 a month, with paid ad budget separate from the fee. Ask any agency what sits on top of its fee.
Be wary of guaranteed leads or revenue, because no agency controls your sales. A commitment on something the agency measures is different. Ask what it covers, how it is measured and what you get if it is missed. Fame guarantees an average of 10% monthly download growth over the first six months, or month seven is free.
Common ones are a growth promise made before anyone has listened to the show, guaranteed revenue, one channel sold as a full strategy, paid downloads with no source, ad spend you cannot see, and a long commitment before you have seen a report.
Want us to run this for you?
Fame starts and grows B2B podcasts that generate pipeline. Tell us who you are trying to reach and we will send a costed proposal within 1 working day.
Related content
- Read moreNovember 18, 2026
The 11 Best Podcast Promotion and Marketing Agencies for B2B (2026)
The best podcast promotion and marketing agencies for B2B in 2026 are Fame, Bumper, Content Allies, JAR, Lower Street, Pacific Content, Podcast Discovery, The Podglomerate, Quill,… - Read moreNovember 11, 2026
Trusted: a B2B podcast works best when buyers already know your name
The most common B2B podcast story goes like this. A company launches a show. The CEO hosts. Twelve episodes later, downloads are flat at 150, the CEO is bored, and the show… - Read moreAugust 11, 2025
The Ultimate Guide To Measuring B2B Podcast ROI: From Downloads To Pipeline Attribution
Most B2B marketers measure podcast success like it's 2015, counting downloads and celebrating vanity metrics while pipeline impact remains a mystery. - Read moreAugust 8, 2025
The ROI Double-Helix: Why Your B2B Podcast Needs Both Guest And Listener Conversion Models
While most brands chase downloads or guest logos, the real ROI happens when you stop treating podcasting as a binary choice.