November 18, 2026Last updated: November 18, 202610 min read11 sections

What to Look For When Hiring a Podcast Booking Agency: 12 Questions to Ask

By Tom Hunt, Founder & CEO, Fame

Tom founded Fame in 2019 and leads the company today, including Fame Search, its AI search agency for B2B companies. LinkedIn

Key Takeaways

  • Get a written definition of a booking. A host saying yes, a recorded interview and a live episode are three different things.
  • Approve the show list before anyone is pitched, and read a sample pitch.
  • Ask what arrives after the recording: clips, written content, who owns them and who chases the episode to live.
  • Ask where every audience number comes from. Most are estimates, which is fine if they are labelled.
  • Score every agency on the same 12 questions and give most credit to answers in writing.

If you are about to pay someone to get your executives onto other people's podcasts, this guide is for you. It gives you 12 questions to put to every podcast booking agency on your shortlist, what a weak answer sounds like, and a scorecard you can copy. Fame sells a booking service, so our own answers are at the end, including the ones that do not flatter us.

To choose a podcast booking agency, ask each one the same 12 questions about show selection, who pitches and in whose name, what counts as a booking, what you get after the recording, how results are tracked, and the full price and terms, then score the answers you can verify.

This is a checklist, not a list of names. If you want names, see our list of the best podcast booking agencies. If you are new to the channel, start with the B2B podcast guesting guide.

Why is comparing podcast booking agencies so hard?

Because the same word, "booking", is counted in different ways, and the number most agencies lead with is the hardest one to check.

One agency counts a booking when a host says yes. Another counts it when the episode is recorded. A third counts it only when the episode is live.

Pricing is just as uneven. Some agencies charge a monthly retainer, some charge per placement, and some sell podcasts as one line of a wider PR retainer.

Then there is audience size. Most podcasts do not publish download figures, so the audience number in a pitch deck is usually an estimate or the host's own claim.

How should an agency choose the shows it pitches you to?

It should start from who your buyers are and build the list from there, and you should see that list before a single pitch is sent.

1. How do you decide which shows to pitch?

Ask for the method, not the result. Is the list built from your buyer persona, or from the shows the agency already has a relationship with?

A weak answer: a list of the biggest shows in a broad category such as "business", with a download figure nobody can source.

2. Do I approve the list before anyone is pitched?

A pitch goes out with your name and your company in it.

A weak answer: "Leave it with us, we know the space." You find out where you were pitched when a host replies.

Who pitches, and in whose name?

You need to know who writes the pitch, which name and email address it is sent from, and who you speak to when something goes wrong.

3. Who writes the pitch, and who does it come from?

Some agencies pitch as themselves on your behalf. Some send from an address that looks like yours. Neither is wrong, but you should know which, and you should read a sample before it goes out.

Ask how many hosts receive the same pitch, too. A message written for one show reads very differently from a template sent to two hundred. Our post on writing a podcast guest pitch shows what a tailored one looks like.

A weak answer: no sample, and no answer on whose name is in the "from" line.

4. Who is my day-to-day contact, and who prepares the speaker?

The person on the sales call is often not the person running the outreach. Ask who is, how you reach them, and what preparation your speaker gets before each recording.

A weak answer: "You will have a dedicated team", with no names.

What counts as a booking, and what is guaranteed?

A booking should have a written definition, and any guarantee should say what happens when a month falls short.

5. How many bookings do I get, and is that number guaranteed?

Ask whether the number is a commitment, a target or an average. Then ask what happens if it is missed: a credit, an extra month, a rollover, or nothing.

A weak answer: "It varies, but clients usually see plenty."

6. What exactly counts as a booking?

Get the definition before you sign. Is it a confirmed recording date, a recorded interview or a published episode? Ask about the edge cases as well. Do shows that charge guests a fee count? Do the agency's own shows count? If your speaker cancels, does that booking still count against your total?

A weak answer: a number of "opportunities" or "introductions", which is not the same thing as a recording in the diary.

What should you get after the recording?

At minimum you should know whether clips and written content are included, who is allowed to use them, and who chases the episode until it is live.

7. What do I receive from each appearance?

An interview that is published once and never mentioned again reaches the host's audience and nobody else. The clips and posts made from it are how the appearance reaches your own audience. Ask whether they are included and how many you get.

Ask who owns them, too. Some agencies assign the content to you. Others keep ownership and give you a licence to use it. Read the clause.

A weak answer: "We can quote for content separately", once you have already signed.

8. What happens if an episode is delayed or never published?

Hosts fall behind and shows go quiet. Ask whether the agency follows each recording through to the publish date, and what it does when one stalls.

A weak answer: the agency's job ends when the calendar invite is sent.

How should results be tracked and reported?

You should be able to see the whole pipeline at any time, and every audience number should come with its source.

9. Can I see where every pitch and booking stands?

Ask to see the actual report or dashboard a client gets, not a description of one. You want to see how many shows were pitched, how many replied, how many are booked, how many are recorded and how many are live.

A weak answer: a list of logos at the end of the quarter.

10. Where do your audience numbers come from?

Ask this about every listener or download figure you are shown, in a proposal or in a report. An estimate is fine if it is labelled as one and the method is explained.

A weak answer: large round numbers with no source.

What should you check on price and contract terms?

Get one all-in monthly figure, then the minimum term, the notice period and what happens to your content if you leave.

11. What is the full price, and what is extra?

Ask for a single total and a list of what it does not cover. The usual extras are set-up fees, content, a media kit or speaker page, and appearance fees charged by the shows themselves.

A weak answer: a figure that only appears after you have shared your budget.

12. What is the minimum term, and how do I leave?

A minimum term is reasonable here. Podcasts schedule weeks ahead and publish weeks after recording, so a one-month test tells you very little. What matters is that the term is stated, the notice period is short, and you know whether pitching carries on during the notice period.

A weak answer: a twelve-month commitment before a single show has been approved, or a renewal you only find in the small print.

What are the red flags when hiring a podcast booking agency?

Six things should make you slow down, and each one needs a clear explanation before you go further.

  • No definition of a booking. If the unit you are paying for is not written down, the count can mean anything.
  • No approval step. Pitches should not go out in your name to shows you have not seen.
  • Paid placements counted as bookings without telling you. Some shows charge guests. That is the show's choice, but you should know when it applies and who is paying.
  • Audience figures with no source. Ask how each number was worked out.
  • Guaranteed leads or revenue. An appearance can be delivered. What listeners do afterwards cannot be promised.
  • The service stops at the recording. Without clips, posts and follow-through to the publish date, most of the value is left on the table.

One red flag is a reason to ask a follow-up question. Several together are a reason to keep looking.

What does a scorecard you can copy look like?

Copy the table below into a spreadsheet, add one column per agency, and score each question from 0 to 2 straight after the call.

Score 0 for no clear answer, 1 for a clear answer with nothing to back it up, and 2 for an answer in writing or one you have checked. The maximum is 24. A 0 on what counts as a booking, approval or contract terms is a reason to pause whatever the total.

AreaQuestionWhat earns a 2
Shows1. Show selectionA written method that starts from your buyers
Shows2. ApprovalYou approve every show before outreach
Pitching3. Pitch and senderA named sender and a sample pitch for your speaker
Pitching4. Contact and prepA named contact and a briefing before each recording
Bookings5. Number and guaranteeA fixed monthly number with a stated remedy
Bookings6. DefinitionOne sentence defining a booking, with rules for paid shows and cancellations
After7. ContentStated clips and written pieces per booking, with ownership in writing
After8. Follow-throughEvery appearance tracked until it is live
Reporting9. PipelineA live view or weekly update by stage
Reporting10. Audience numbersEstimates labelled as estimates, with the method
Cost11. Full priceOne all-in figure with exclusions listed
Cost12. Term and exitMinimum term, notice and renewal in one paragraph

The same twelve questions apply if you decide to run this yourself. We set out that choice in hire an agency or do it in-house.

How does Fame answer these questions?

Fame publishes this guide and sells Fame Connect, our podcast booking service, so read these as our own answers and put them to the same test as anyone else's. Fame Connect has booked 2,500+ interviews since 2020.

  • Show selection (1). A strategist agrees your buyer persona and two or three angles with you. The target list is built from those buyers. Shows are scored on the substance of real episodes, not on download claims, using our B2B Podcast Index.
  • Approval (2). Every show we want to pitch lands in your portal for a yes, maybe or no with a note.
  • Pitch and sender (3). Your account manager runs the outreach, and nothing goes out in your name that you have not seen.
  • Contact and prep (4). A dedicated account manager, reachable by email or Slack, who briefs you before each recording.
  • Number and guarantee (5). Two external bookings a month, guaranteed in the plan.
  • Definition (6). We track four stages: opportunity, booked, recorded and live. We do not do pay-to-play placements. If a show you want only offers paid appearances, we tell you and you decide whether to pay that show directly. The plan also includes one internal booking a quarter, which is a guest slot on a show Fame produces for a client. It is counted separately from the two external bookings.
  • Content (7). Five video clips and four written assets per booking, included in the price.
  • Follow-through (8). Every appearance is tracked to live.
  • Pipeline (9). You log into a portal that counts each stage, with the drop-off between stages visible to you and to us. You can look around a demo portal with a demo company's data before you speak to us.
  • Audience numbers (10). Our case studies report estimated listeners, estimated minutes listened and cost per listener. The Gong case study is an example: 10+ podcasts in under four months for Gong's CMO, an estimated 34,500 listeners and about $0.30 per listener.
  • Full price (11). One plan on our pricing page: $2,000 a month, which works out at about $1,000 per external booking. It covers the bookings and the content. There is no separate production fee and no fee to the shows.
  • Term and exit (12). No trial. The minimum term is three months, and you give 30 days' written notice to stop when your term ends.

Where Fame Connect is not the right fit

  • You want to test with one month. There is no trial and the minimum is three months.
  • You mainly want the biggest shows. We book on relevance first.
  • Your buyers are not B2B, or are outside our main markets. We book mostly US and UK shows, with Europe, Canada and Australia where your buyers are there.
  • Your speaker cannot make time. Our terms ask for replies within 48 hours, because slow replies lose bookings.
  • Nobody will post the clips. If the content never goes out, the episode reaches the host's audience but not yours.
  • You want your own show. That is a different service, Fame Podcast, with its own price. Fame Connect does not include it.

More on podcast guesting

Want your executives on the shows your buyers already listen to? Fame Connect is our podcast booking service for B2B companies: two external bookings a month, with five clips and four written assets from each, for $2,000 a month.

Share thisLinkedInEmail

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Ask each agency the same 12 questions and compare the answers in writing. They cover six areas: how shows are chosen, who pitches and in whose name, what counts as a booking and what is guaranteed, what you get after the recording, how results are tracked, and the full price and contract terms.

Want us to run this for you?

Fame starts and grows B2B podcasts that generate pipeline. Tell us who you are trying to reach and we will send a costed proposal within 1 working day.