November 18, 2026Last updated: November 18, 20268 min read8 sections

Third-Party Lists Are the New Backlinks

By Tom Hunt, Founder & CEO, Fame

Tom founded Fame in 2019 and leads the company today, including Fame Search, its AI search agency for B2B companies. LinkedIn

Key Takeaways

  • When a buyer asks for options, engines tend to cite pages that are already lists.
  • A list placement carries context about who you suit, so what the list says about you matters as much as being on it.
  • Start from the lists already cited for your tracked questions, not from famous publications.
  • Earn placement by sending editors corrections and verifiable facts, and never hide a paid or other relationship.
  • If you publish your own list, disclose that you publish it and that you are on it.

For twenty years the backlink was the vote that decided who got found. In AI answers, the nearest equivalent appears to be a place on the "best of" lists that engines retrieve when a buyer asks for options. If you are not on the lists being cited for your category, you tend to be missing from the answer, which is why list work sits near the top of the plan at any serious GEO agency.

I mean the comparison loosely. A list placement is not a ranking factor anyone has documented, and the engines do not publish how they choose sources. But the pattern shows up often enough in the answers we read every week that I think B2B teams should treat lists the way they once treated links: as something to earn on purpose.

Why do AI answers lean on "best of" lists?

Think about what a buyer actually asks. "What are the best contract management tools for a mid-sized legal team?" is a request for a list. The simplest way for an engine to answer is to find pages that are already lists and summarize them.

The data fits that reading. In an Ahrefs study of 750 prompts from December 2025, "Best X" lists were 43.8% of cited page types, and brands higher on third-party lists were more likely to be recommended. The prompts were written by the author and the finding is a correlation, so it cannot tell you that one more placement will move your numbers.

There is a second reason, which is about who is speaking. Your own site says you are good. A list says it in someone else's words, next to your competitors. Aja Frost, who runs SEO at HubSpot, put it bluntly at INBOUND: AI engines don't care about backlinks, they care about brand mentions. Ahrefs' numbers lean the same way. Analyzing 75,000 brands, it found branded web mentions correlated with AI visibility at 0.656 to 0.709, while Domain Rating came in at 0.266 to 0.326. Ahrefs notes itself that correlation is not causation, and well-known brands earn all of these signals at once.

The analogy is useful, and it breaks in a few places that matter.

BacklinkList placement
What it isA link to your page from another siteYour company named and described on a page comparing options
What it carriesAuthority, passed to a URLContext: what you do, who you suit, how you compare
Does it need a link?Yes, by definitionNot necessarily. The mention and the description appear to do the work
Where it countsAcross everything the page ranks forMostly on the questions that list gets retrieved for
How stable it isLasts while the link stays upThe list can be re-ranked, rewritten or dropped from answers
How it gets abusedPaid links and link farmsPay-to-play lists with no method or disclosure

Two rows deserve a comment. First, context. A backlink says "this page matters". A list entry says "this company is the budget option for small teams", and the engine may repeat that sentence to your buyer. What the list says about you matters as much as being on it. Second, scope. A list about HR software for European companies helps you on that question. It does little for anything else, so a pile of unrelated placements is worth far less than three on the lists your buyers' questions actually pull up.

Which lists matter for your company?

The ones already being cited for your questions. That sounds obvious, yet most outreach starts from a list of famous publications.

The method is simple:

  1. Run your buyer questions several times in each engine and save every cited URL.
  2. Pull out the third-party pages and group them: lists, directories, review sites, editorial, community.
  3. Count how often each one appears. A page cited across many answers and several weeks is worth more than one that showed up once.
  4. Mark the ones where you honestly fit the criteria.
  5. Note what each says about you today, if anything, and whether it is correct.

Do not rule out a list because the site looks small. Ahrefs found 35% of cited best lists sat on low-authority domains. Do not chase them blindly either: the study's author described those pages as often questionable, and being cited today does not make a page a durable asset. The same method works per engine, and our Perplexity guide walks through it for one of them.

How do you earn honest placement?

By being useful to the person who maintains the list. Editors of comparison pages have a standing problem: their information goes stale and vendors only email to ask for favors.

So send something they can use:

  • A correction. If the list has your pricing, product name or category wrong, that is the easiest email to write and the most likely to get a reply.
  • Verifiable facts. Published pricing, who you serve, who you are not for. Link to the page on your site where each fact lives.
  • A proof point they can check, such as a public customer story.
  • Original data they might cite elsewhere on their site.
  • A plain statement of where you fit and where a competitor is the better choice. Editors trust a vendor who admits limits.

And a few things I would not do:

  • Pay for placement on low-quality sites just to appear.
  • Ask to be ranked first. Ask to be described accurately.
  • Send the same template to 200 sites. Fifteen relevant lists, approached properly, is a better month.
  • Hide a relationship. If money or any other arrangement sits behind a placement, the page should say so.

At Fame we draft this outreach for clients, and they approve every message before it goes anywhere. We do not run a link-building program.

Should you publish your own "best of" list?

You can, if you are honest about it. We do. Fame publishes a list of AEO agencies for B2B that includes Fame, and it carries a disclosure near the top that we publish the list, sell the service and are not in a neutral position.

The evidence on whether this works is mixed. Ahrefs ran a self-promotion experiment, publishing 34 pages across five domains and tracking 9,886 answers:

  • For a new brand, 82% of the 72 newly filled prompt slots came from answers citing one of the company's own pages.
  • For an established brand, only 6% of new mentions came from its own pages. The other 94% came from third-party content.
  • 43% of answers citing a conference page still did not mention the brand, and recommended competing events instead.

It is a small, single-brand experiment on Ahrefs' own products, so treat it as a hint. My reading is that your own list can get a newer brand into the conversation, and it does not replace being on other people's.

If you publish one, hold it to the standard you would want from anyone else:

  1. Disclose at the top that you publish the list and that you are on it.
  2. Explain how you chose and ordered the entries.
  3. Take competitor facts from their own public pages, and show the date you checked.
  4. Say who each option is not for, including yours.
  5. Keep it updated, with a visible date.

The test is whether the page is useful to a reader who ends up picking someone else. If it is, you have published a resource. If it is not, you have published an ad in the shape of a list, and readers can tell.

What are the limits of this approach?

There are four worth knowing before you put budget behind it.

The published numbers conflict. One vendor study found about 69% of ChatGPT citations go to brand websites. Another found 94.85% of citations were third-party sources. They measure different things and they do not settle the question, so make your own site the best source on your company and work the lists as well.

List answers are unstable. Ahrefs found "best X" questions were among the least stable for citations. A placement can be cited one week and absent the next, which is why you measure with repeated runs over several weeks.

A citation is not a recommendation. You can be on a cited list and still be left out of the answer. Position and description on the list both appear to matter.

The category will get spammed. Backlinks did. As more people notice that lists get cited, more low-effort lists will appear, and I would expect the engines to get pickier. Earned placements on pages with a real method should hold up better than bought ones, though that is a prediction and I cannot prove it.

How do you know it worked?

Track the same questions before and after, with several runs each, and log two things separately: whether the list is cited, and whether you are named in the answer. If the list is cited and you are still missing, look at how you are described on it. If the list is no longer cited at all, your effort belongs elsewhere.

Give it time. Editors can take weeks to reply, and an updated page may take time to be picked up again. Review after a full quarter, and compare with whatever else you changed in the same period. Our ChatGPT guide shows how list work fits beside page work, the 90-day plan puts it on a calendar, and the complete guide to B2B AI search covers the rest.

Fame has no client results to report on this yet. On our own site, the share of tracked AI answers citing fame.so went from 38% on June 1 to 76% on October 30, 2026, but many things changed over that period and I cannot tell you how much of it came from lists.

Want your company named in AI answers? Fame Search is our AI search agency for B2B companies: weekly tracking across four AI engines and one action on your site every day, for $2,000 a month.

Share thisLinkedInEmail

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Nobody outside the AI companies knows for certain. A request for the best options is a request for a list, so pages that are already lists are a natural source. In an Ahrefs study of 750 prompts, "Best X" lists were 43.8% of cited page types.

Want us to run this for you?

Fame starts and grows B2B podcasts that generate pipeline. Tell us who you are trying to reach and we will send a costed proposal within 1 working day.