November 18, 20268 min read6 sections

Follower Count Is the Wrong Number: How to Judge a B2B Creator

By Tom Hunt, Founder & CEO, Fame

Tom founded Fame in 2019 and leads the company today, including Fame Search, its AI search agency for B2B companies. LinkedIn

Key Takeaways

  • Follower count shows how many people once followed a creator. It does not show who they are or whether they still read.
  • Judge a B2B creator on who comments, the ICP-engagement percentage, whether they do the buyer's job, and consistency across posts.
  • Choose creators on how concentrated their audience is in your market. Use size to decide how many creators you need.
  • Fame's 5,000-follower minimum is a floor for reach. It is not how creators are selected.

Judge a B2B creator by who engages with their posts, not by how many people follow them. Read the comments, check the job titles and companies behind them, and ask what share match your ideal customer profile. A small creator whose commenters are your buyers will usually beat a large one whose audience is everyone.

That is my opinion, and I hold it as someone with a large follower count of my own. I have 224,000 followers on LinkedIn and I have run sponsored posts myself. The follower number is the least useful thing I could tell a sponsor about my account.

Why follower count misleads in B2B

Follower count is popular because it is easy. It is public, it is one number, and it sorts a spreadsheet. But in B2B you are buying attention from a narrow group of people: the roles that choose, approve or block a purchase in your category. Follower count tells you nothing about whether those people are in the audience.

The audience mix is hidden

A follower total does not say who the followers are. A creator who writes about sales may be followed by sales leaders, but also by students, job seekers, recruiters, other creators and people selling to the same audience you are. Each counts as one follower. If your product is bought by revenue operations leaders at mid-sized software companies, most of a broad audience is not your market, and you pay for all of it anyway.

This matters more in B2B than in consumer marketing. A consumer brand can sell to almost anyone who sees the post. You can sell to a small fraction of any feed, so the mix is the whole question.

Followers are a record of the past

A follower count only goes up. People follow once and rarely unfollow. So the number includes everyone who followed years ago for a different topic, in a different job, or during one post that travelled far outside the creator's usual subject. Many have since changed roles or stopped reading. The count describes who was once interested. A sponsored post reaches whoever is reading now.

Engagement can be manufactured

The obvious fix is to look at likes and comments instead. That helps, but only if you check who is behind them. Engagement pods are groups who agree to engage with each other's posts whatever those posts say. LinkedIn does not allow engagement pods and says it limits their reach. A pod can still make an account look busier than it is, and the people in it are rarely your buyers. Our guide to LinkedIn engagement pods covers the warning signs.

Following is not reading

A post is not shown to every follower. Each post earns its own distribution. My own sponsored posts show how loose the link is. The ones published on Fame's site range from 5,702 impressions to 4,570,951, and the largest was also promoted with the brand's paid budget. Those are my posts, on one account, with broadly the same followers each time. They say nothing about what another creator will do, but they do show that a follower count does not predict what a single post will reach.

What to look at instead

I look at four things, in this order.

Who comments, and what they do for a living

Comments are the most honest public signal on LinkedIn, because each one has a name, a job title and a company attached. Open the profiles. Are these people in the roles you sell to, at the kind of company you sell to? Do the comments respond to the argument in the post, or could they sit under any post?

ICP-engagement percentage

This turns the comment check into a number you can compare. Take the people who engaged with a post, work out how many match your ideal customer profile, and express that as a share of the total. I would put it at the top of any creator report, above impressions. Estimate it by hand before you book anyone, and ask for it afterwards. The definition is in our influencer marketing glossary, and our guide to B2B influencer marketing ROI explains how it fits with the other measures.

Whether the creator does the buyer's job

The strongest B2B creators are practitioners. A finance director writing about finance operations attracts other finance people, because the posts are useful to someone doing that work. A product mention then carries weight, because the reader assumes the writer would know whether the product is any good. A professional content creator who writes about business in general can have a far bigger audience and far less authority with your buyer. Ask a simple question: has this person done the job my buyer does, or closely advised people who do?

Consistency across posts

One post proves nothing. Look across several months. Check that the right people keep turning up, not only on the one post that went wide, and that the pattern looks natural. Real engagement moves with the topic: some posts land, some do not. Numbers that look the same every time, whatever the subject, deserve a question.

Small vs large creators: when each fits

The micro versus macro debate is usually framed as a question of size. I think it is a question of concentration. How much of this creator's audience is your market?

Smaller creators tend to be more concentrated. They often write about one subject, for people in one kind of role, because that is the work they do. Their audience followed them for that subject. If you sell to a narrow market, several small, concentrated creators will usually put you in front of more of your buyers than one large generalist.

Smaller creators have limits too. Each post reaches fewer people, so you need more of them, which means more briefs, more approvals and more relationships to manage. One post from one small creator tells you very little.

Larger creators fit in a different set of cases:

  • Your market is broad. If you sell to most businesses, or to a role that exists in every company, a wide audience is not waste.
  • You are launching a category or a name. When the aim is for many people to hear of you once, reach does matter.
  • The large creator is still a practitioner. Some big accounts grew by writing about one job for years. Size and concentration can exist together. Check the comments and you will see it.

So the rule I would use is this. Choose on concentration first. Use size to decide how many creators you need, not which ones. Our LinkedIn influencer marketing playbook covers how to plan that across a quarter.

A five-check scorecard

Answer each question with yes, partly or no. Follower count is not on it.

CheckThe questionWhat a "no" looks like
1. Commenter rolesDo the people commenting hold the job titles you sell to?Mostly other creators, students, recruiters or vendors
2. ICP-engagement %Does a meaningful share of engagers match your ideal customer profile?You struggle to find a single target account in the list
3. Does the jobHas the creator done your buyer's job, or advised people who do?They write about business in general, from the outside
4. ConsistencyDo the right people turn up across several months of posts?One post that travelled, and little else
5. Real conversationDo comments answer the post, and does the creator reply?Generic praise that could sit under any post

A creator with five yeses and a small following is a better bet than one with two yeses and a large one. I have not set a pass mark for check two on purpose. What counts as a good ICP-engagement percentage depends on how narrow your market is, so compare creators with each other, not with a benchmark.

The scorecard tells you what to judge. For how to do each check step by step, including sample sizes and the questions to ask a creator, see how to find B2B influencers on LinkedIn.

Why Fame still sets a 5,000-follower minimum

If follower count is the wrong number, why does Fame use one? Every creator we place has at least 5,000 followers.

The answer is that a minimum and a selection criterion are different things. A sponsored post has to reach enough people to be worth briefing, approving and reporting on. Below a certain audience size, even a perfectly concentrated creator cannot give a post much distribution. The 5,000 figure is a floor for reach. It does not rank anyone above it.

Once a creator is over the floor, the follower number stops mattering to us. A creator just over the floor who passes the five checks goes on a shortlist ahead of a far larger one who does not.

Related reading: what to look for when hiring a B2B influencer marketing agency, 13 tactics for a campaign that is already running, what sales should do after a creator post, nine B2B influencer marketing mistakes and their fixes and using LinkedIn creators for account-based marketing.

How Fame Influencer works

Fame Influencer is one plan: $7,000 a month for 10 LinkedIn creator placements a quarter, with creator fees included. A placement is one sponsored post on one creator's own LinkedIn profile. Creators come from practitioners on the 300+ B2B shows Fame has produced, and are vetted for engagement pods and comment farms. You get a brief and approval on every post.

The reporting follows the argument in this post. Monthly reports name every engager by company and role, and give the ICP-engagement percentage and a blended CPM against LinkedIn Ads. There is also a reach floor of at least 250,000 impressions a quarter. If a quarter falls short, Fame adds placements or paid spend at no extra cost.

There is one free placement in month one and nothing to pay until the first post is live. You can cancel after month one if you are not happy with the shortlist or first posts. Otherwise there is a three-month minimum, then it runs month to month. See full pricing for the detail.

Share thisLinkedInEmail

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Choose on who engages with their posts, not how many people follow them. Check that commenters hold the job titles you sell to, estimate what share of engagers match your ideal customer profile, confirm the creator has done your buyer's job, and look for the same pattern across several months of posts.

Want us to run this for you?

Fame Influencer places sponsored posts with vetted LinkedIn creators and names who engaged. The price is published: $7,000 a month for 10 placements a quarter.